1998年年會論文 -巿場競爭與媒體表現之相關性研究
篇名
巿場競爭與媒體表現之相關性研究
Market Competition and Media Performance: Market competition and media performance
作者
李秀珠、王佩華、江靜之
Li, Shu-Chu Sarrina、Wang, Peng Hua、Chiang, Chin Chih
中文摘要
媒體經濟學家已達成一個共識,那就是,影響媒體表現的關鍵因素在於巿場結構,然而,對於巿場結構如何影響媒體表現,媒體經濟學家卻有不同之看法,有些學者主張所有權集中對媒體表現具有正面之影響,所以,巿場競爭與媒體表現具有反面之關係(Burnett﹐1992 ; Schumpeter﹐1950)。另有些學者則持相反之看法,認為巿場集中不能提昇媒體之表現,而且對媒體之表現具有負面之作用。 因此,此派學者主張,巿場競爭與媒體表現具有正向關係,提昇媒體表現之關鍵在於開放媒體巿場,增加巿場之競爭程度(Coser et al.﹐1982 ; Litman﹐1979 ; Peterson & Berger﹐1975 ; Rothenbuhler & Dimmick﹐1982 ; Ryan﹐1985)。

本研究的主要目的乃是檢視競爭與媒體表現之相關性。 本研究以節目內容多樣性作為評估媒體表現之面向,而節目內容多樣性則以3個指標來加以評估,(1) 是黃金時段連續劇之平均集數,(2) 是黃金時段連續劇節目類型之多樣性,及 (3) 8點檔主要男女演員之重複性。本研究收集了1990年至1997年8年之資料進行內容分析,分析之結果發現,競爭與多樣性具有正向之關係,競爭加速了8點檔之淘汰率,使得其平均集數因而減少,競爭也提昇了8點檔及9點半檔節目類型之多樣性。最後,競爭之加強也促使8點檔主要男女演員之重複性降低,所以綜合本研究之分析結果,我們發現,巿場競爭帶來了更高品質之媒體表現。
英文摘要
The relationship between media performance and market structure has long been a major concern by many media economists who believe that media performance is determined by market structure. However, these analysts disagree themselves about what kind of relationship exists between media performance and market structure. Some media economists assert there is a positive relationship between market concentration and media performance, while others don ’t take such a positive view about market concentration and instead see a negative relationship between market concentration and media performance (Adams﹐1993 ; Burnett﹐1992 ; Coser et al.﹐1982 ; Davis & Walker﹐1990 ; Litman﹐1979 ; Peterson & Berger ﹐ 1975 ; Rothenbuhler & Dimmick﹐1982 ; Ryan﹐1985 ; Schumpeter﹐1950 ; Bagdikian﹐1985 ; Compaigne﹐1985)。

This study investigates this issue by examining market competition and its relationship with content diversity of the prime-time dramas by the three TV networks in Taiwan. The data regarding the prime-time dramas from 1990 to 1997 were collected for data analysis of this study. The results support a positive relationship between market competition and content diversity of TV dramas. The implications of the findings from this study were discussed in the paper.
中文關鍵詞
市場競爭,媒體表現,黃金時段,內容多樣性
英文關鍵詞
market competition,media performance,prime time,content diversity
發表日期
授權狀況
已授權